Chapter 2.3 The Optimal Launch Angle
From Explico Playground — Motion, with changes after version 1.0.0, not yet released. Interactive version: https://danieltuzes.github.io/explico/playground/projectiles/optimal-launch-angle/
By (2.1.1), the Range depends on the Launch angle only through sin(2𝜃). The previous chapter derives that equation. For 0∘≤𝜃≤90∘, the argument 2𝜃 is between 0∘ and 180∘. On this interval, the sine has its maximum value, 1, at 90∘. So for a fixed launch speed, the range is largest at 2𝜃=90∘, i.e., at 𝜃=45∘. The explorer in Figure 2.1.1 shows this result. Diagram 2.3.1 shows the inputs to the search for this launch angle.
2.3.1 A polynomial maximum, no calculus
This section finds the same launch angle as the maximum of a polynomial. For 0∘≤𝜃≤90∘, the product sin(𝜃)cos(𝜃) is not negative. So the range is largest where the square of this product is largest. Let 𝑢 be the Squared sine of the launch angle: 𝑢=sin2(𝜃). Rewriting the square of the product in terms of 𝑢 gives a second-order polynomial:
The graph of this polynomial is a downward parabola with roots at 𝑢=0 and 𝑢=1. A downward parabola has its maximum halfway between its roots, so the polynomial is largest at 𝑢=1 2. Converting this value of 𝑢 back to a launch angle gives the Optimal launch angle:
Setting the derivative of the polynomial to zero gives the same vertex (show how). But the symmetry of the parabola gives the vertex without a derivative. In (2.1.1), the launch speed appears only in the factor 𝑣0 2, which does not depend on the launch angle. A positive constant factor does not change the position of the maximum. So the Optimal launch angle is 45∘ for every launch speed. a checks the vertex numerically and graphically.
Show the full calculation using calculus.
Take the derivative of the expanded polynomial and set it to zero:
The solution of this equation is 𝑢=1 2.
2.3.2 Complementary launch angles give equal ranges
Two launch angles are complementary if their sum is 90∘. The Complementary launch angle of 𝜃 is 𝜃′=90∘−𝜃. On this page the prime marks this angle and does not mean a derivative. For complementary launch angles, sin(2𝜃′)=sin(180∘−2𝜃)=sin(2𝜃). So two complementary launch angles give equal ranges. For example, the range at a launch angle of 30∘ equals the range at a launch angle of 60∘. The Optimal launch angle is the only launch angle that is its own complement.
The curve is symmetric about 45∘. A launch angle of 20∘ and a launch angle of 70∘ give the same range. The trajectory at 20∘ is lower and has a shorter time of flight than the trajectory at 70∘.
Memo a: Checking the polynomial vertex: its values on both sides of the vertex, and its downward-parabola shape
Evaluating the polynomial at the vertex, 𝑢=1 2, gives its maximum value:
Two values of 𝑢 at equal distances from the vertex give equal values of the polynomial, and both values are smaller than the maximum.
| Squared sine of the launch angle | Value of the polynomial |
|---|---|
0 | 0 |
1 4 | 3 16 |
1 2 | 1 4 |
3 4 | 3 16 |
1 | 0 |
(2.3.4), Table 2.3.1, and Figure 2.3.2 are inside the memo. A reference to each of them also works while the memo is closed.
Knowledge check 2.3.1: Optimal launch angle
- 1.
For a fixed launch speed over level ground, with no air resistance, which launch angle maximizes range?
- •(a) 30∘
- •(b) 45∘
- •(c) 60∘
- •(d) 90∘
Answers: end of the chapter.
Notation
On this page, □′ is not an operator. The prime marks the complementary launch angle, not a derivative.
Complementary launch angle. The launch angle whose sum with a given launch angle is 90 degrees. Units: degrees above the horizontal.
Optimal launch angle. The launch angle that maximizes range for a given fixed launch speed, over level ground. Units: degrees above the horizontal.
Squared sine of the launch angle. The squared sine of the launch angle, used as the variable in the range polynomial. Units: dimensionless.
Gravitational acceleration. The magnitude of gravitational acceleration, treated as constant near the ground. Units: meters per second squared.
Launch angle. The angle between a projectile's initial velocity and the horizontal ground at launch. Units: degrees above the horizontal.
Launch speed. The object's speed at the start of the scenario being analyzed — its initial velocity in a straight-line problem, or its launch speed the instant a projectile leaves the ground. Units: meters per second.
Range. Total horizontal distance a projectile covers before it returns to its launch height. Units: meters.
Time. Elapsed time since the object was launched or released, measured in seconds. Units: seconds after launch.
Answers to the knowledge checks
Knowledge check 2.3.1: Optimal launch angle
- 1.(b) 45∘. The range is proportional to sin(2𝜃). For launch angles from 0° to 90°, sin(2𝜃) has its maximum at 2𝜃=90°. So 𝜃∗=45°.